What if millions more Americans could qualify for Medicare at a fraction of the cost many assume?
That possibility isn’t just theoretical. It’s supported by a little-noticed Congressional Budget Office (CBO) analysis that deserves renewed attention.
In May 2022, CBO examined what would happen if Congress lowered the Medicare eligibility age from 65 to 60. Its finding was striking: The expansion would increase federal deficits by just $155 billion over six years, or approximately $26 billion annually.
That annual cost is equivalent to roughly 2% of what Medicare currently spends in a single year.
But the most revealing part of the analysis is how CBO arrived at its estimate.
Although Medicare spending would increase by approximately $371 billion, much of that cost would be offset by savings elsewhere in the federal health care system and additional federal revenue, including:
$112 billion in reduced Medicaid spending.
$95 billion in reduced federal health insurance subsidies.
$53 billion in additional federal tax revenue associated with changes in employer-sponsored health insurance coverage.
CBO also projected that employer-sponsored health insurance premiums would decline by approximately 0.8% and that roughly 150,000 Americans would retire earlier because Medicare would provide another coverage option.
The takeaway: Expanding Medicare doesn’t simply add costs to the federal budget. It also reduces costs elsewhere.
With Medicare expansion gaining momentum in Congress, it’s time for lawmakers to request an updated CBO analysis examining eligibility at ages 60, 55, and 50. We suspect that lowering the Medicare eligibility age may cost less today than CBO projected four years ago.
At The Progressive Health Care Project, we believe the debate should focus on more than the federal cost of Medicare expansion. It should also consider the potential savings and economic benefits for American families and businesses.
Let’s get the updated CBO numbers and have that debate.

