OP-ED | October 8
By The Progressive Health Care Project
A Medicare card is a promise of care. Keeping that promise requires doctors and medical practices that can afford to provide it.
Congress cannot protect Medicare simply by defending who qualifies for coverage. It must also sustain the physicians and the medical practices that patients depend on.
Consider what Medicare pays a surgeon to replace a worn-out joint and help a patient walk without pain. In 2026, the national professional payment is approximately $1,162 for a total hip replacement and $1,160 for a total knee replacement.
That payment is practice revenue, not the surgeon’s take-home pay. It helps cover staff salaries, malpractice insurance, office expenses, technology and billing. For these procedures, the surgical payment also includes routine postoperative care during a 90-day global period. The responsibility continues long after the patient leaves the operating room.
The problem reaches far beyond surgery. According to the American Medical Association, Medicare physician payment fell approximately 33 percent between 2001 and 2026 after adjusting for inflation in practice costs. Over a generation, the payment system lost roughly one-third of its purchasing power.
Medical practices cannot indefinitely absorb that reimbursement erosion. When payments fail to keep pace with the cost of delivering care, patients face the risk of fewer appointment options, longer waits and greater difficulty finding a physician who accepts Medicare.
Congress should respond with a substantial investment: a one-time, 100 percent increase in Medicare physician fee schedule rates, permanently doubling the payment baseline, followed by annual updates tied to the Medicare Economic Index, which measures changes in practice costs.
Doubling rates would go beyond restoring the purchasing power lost since 2001. It would make a deliberate investment in the capacity Medicare needs for the future. Congress should pursue that investment openly, rather than continue relying on temporary fixes that leave the underlying problem unresolved.
The increase should support primary care, specialty care and the other professionals paid through the fee schedule. Congress should fund it without offsetting cuts elsewhere in that schedule and protect beneficiaries from higher premiums and cost-sharing attributable to the change.
The obvious objection is cost. Doubling physician payments sounds like doubling Medicare’s budget. It’s not and the numbers tell a different story.
The 2025 Medicare Trustees Report shows that Medicare spent $71.4 billion directly on traditional Medicare physician fee schedule services in 2024, compared with approximately $1.122 trillion in total program expenditures. Those direct physician payments represented only 6.4 percent of total Medicare spending.
Using that historical spending as an illustration, and holding service volume and mix constant, doubling those direct payments would add approximately $71 billion annually—an amount equal to less than 7 percent of Medicare’s 2024 total budget.
That is a substantial investment. But it puts the proposal in perspective: a dramatic increase in physician payment does not mean a comparable percentage increase in total Medicare spending.
Those of us who support expanding Medicare eligibility should lead this fight. Bringing more people into Medicare requires investing in the doctors and practices that will care for the patients. Broader coverage and dependable access must advance together.
Patients need more than an insurance card. They need a doctor who can see them, a practice that can stay open and care they can obtain when they need it.
Congress must back Medicare’s promise with fair payments to doctors that make that care possible.

